Christian Mingle and eharmony have been two of the biggest names in the online dating scene for more than two decades. Both platforms assist singles in finding long-term relationships but use different approaches. eharmony is known for its in-depth compatibility quiz, while Christian Mingle focuses on faith-based relationships.

If you’re looking for a serious partner but are unsure which platform is worth your time and money, it’s good to gather all the information first. In this article, our experts compare eharmony and Christian Mingle head-to-head so you can learn the details about their features, user base, and success stories.

Cost | User Base | Safety Features | Success Stories

Cost Breakdown: eharmony Is a Bit Pricier

Online dating plays a significant role in modern love. According to a survey from the Pew Research Center, approximately 20% of current committed relationships in the U.S. began online. You can join most online dating sites for free, and Christian Mingle and eharmony are no exception. But you may need to upgrade to a paid membership to get the most out of your online dating experience.

Category Rating
★★★★★ 4.7/5.0
  • Over 2 million people have found love here
  • Users can filter their match recommendations by age or city
  • Compatibility Quiz identifies common interests, lifestyles, and goals

You can begin using eharmony as a free member to browse profiles to find compatible individuals. Don’t expect too much from eharmony’s free membership, as profile pictures are not visible to anyone with a free membership, and sending private messaging is also a premium feature.

Upgrading to a premium membership starts at more than $60 per month. The high price tag acts as a filter to repel casual hookup seekers. Only those who are financially stable and ready to start serious relationships will invest in eharmony premium membership. 

But, due to today’s economic challenges, eharmony is reducing the price by up to 40% to make it more affordable for online daters. 

Signing up as a premium member of eharmony is a serious commitment because of the price and the fact that you must commit to a minimum six-month membership. That stability enables eharmony to compile lists of singles who are willing to invest their money and time in finding serious life partners. Once you become a premium member, make sure you connect with the profiles suggested to you to make it worth the investment. 

Category Rating
★★★★ 4.3/5.0

Just like eharmony, you can get started on Christian Mingle for free. But there is not much you can do as a free member of the platform because sending unlimited messages, seeing profile photos, seeing who’s liked your profiles, and joining chat rooms are included in premium features.

Christian Mingle premium memberships start around $45 per month. The premium membership is available in one, three, or six-month commitment levels. 

Joining Christian Mingle as a premium member gives you more wiggle room as you can try it for as little as one month to see if the platform suits your expectations. It may be worth upgrading your membership if you want to find a Christian partner. And the longer you commit to the subscription, the more money you can save. 

User Base: You’ll Meet More Christian Singles on the Christian Mingle App

Christian Mingle and eharmony cater to singles looking for serious relationships. The difference is that Christian Mingle focuses on faith-based relationships, while eharmony prioritizes psychology to find your perfect match. 

eharmony: Find the Right Partners with Low Divorce Rate

eharmony launched in early 2000 and aimed to help singles find serious relationships that lead to marriage. Today, eharmony claims to help someone find love every 14 minutes.

Every day, about 15,000 people fill out eharmony’s personality profile to identify their likes, dislikes, emotional temperament, lifestyle, core beliefs, hobbies, dealbreakers, and relationship goals. This test becomes the basis of the compatibility scores you’ll see on every dating profile suggested to you on eharmony. After 20 years of doing business, data shows that couples who met through eharmony have a 3.86% divorce rate. That means people don’t just find partners on eharmony; they find the right partners.

Christian Mingle: A Hub for Christian Connections

Christian Mingle is the undisputed leader in Christian online dating. Since its launch in 2001, Christian Mingle has seen its user base grow to more than 16 million singles worldwide and 3.5 million monthly visitors and counting. The platform is the best dating pool for you to find your Christian partner because of its mission to strengthen and support Christian marriages.

Bride and groom standing in front of a priest during a church wedding
If you’re looking for a partner who shares your faith and vision for a holy marriage, Christian Mingle is a great dating platform to try.

The dating platform’s algorithm helps Christian singles find compatible dates, which can hopefully lead to serious partnerships. According to a survey of American Christians, 29% of all Christian marriages that originated online started on Christian Mingle. No wonder many Christian Mingle users don’t mind recommending the platform to a friend.

When you hang out on Christian Mingle, you’ll meet relationship-minded Christians or people of other faiths who want to date a Christian. You can rely on the curated match suggestions or take an active approach using specific filters to browse on your own. This will cut through the noise and speed up the process of finding someone who meets your standards.

Safety Features: eharmony Has a Good Reputation

The main reason people visit online dating sites is to find a meaningful connection with a partner. Safety shouldn’t be a concern as long as legit dating sites look out for users. From swiping games to personality quizzes, the goal is always to safely bring people together in the real world. Now, let’s take a closer look at how Christian Mingle and eharmony make reliable match suggestions between vetted people.

eharmony’s Personality Test Highlights Compatibility & Authenticity

A new eharmony member can take its famous personality quiz to delve into their character and personality traits. This personality test results create a Personality Profile that highlights temperament, values, goals, and other attractive qualities.

eharmony uses your quiz results to find matches with high compatibility scores ranging from 60 to 140. The score will vary by individual as it depends on mutual compatibility. The app recommends you connect with matches with a score of 100 or higher.

eharmony logo on a cellphone in front of a big red heart
eharmony’s detailed personality quiz helps to ensure you receive the best matches for you.

You can filter the match recommendation by common traits, such as age, height, religion, and ethnicity, to narrow down your favorites. Or you can get hyper-specific to filter based on income, education, smoking habits, and if a match has children or wants children, among other characteristics.

The combination of eharmony’s high price tag and intensive personality test makes this platform pretty much free of fake profiles. If you find anything that feels suspicious, you can flag it, and the eharmony safety team will investigate further.

Christian Mingle Vets Profiles & Keeps the Site Clean

Christian Mingle has been an established online dating site for faith-driven individuals for decades. The service has sparked countless courtships and marriages among Christians around the world. When you join Christian Mingle, the algorithm will provide a curated list of daily matches. You can filter your recommendations based on gender, age, religion, location, and relationship type.

When you find someone appealing, you can send winks to show interest. If you’re still a free member, you can’t initiate conversation but can respond to every message you receive. Christian Mingle also equips you with helpful safety tips, including how to pick a public place to meet up, go at your own pace, trust your instincts, and never share financial or personal information.

Man sitting with hands in prayer in front of his laptop and Bible
If you are a person of faith, Christian Mingle is a safe site for finding a Christian partner.

Christian Mingle is dedicated to ensuring its dating community remains clear of fake profiles, inappropriate behavior, and online scammers. Every photo uploaded on Christian Mingle needs to be approved before it appears on the site. Typically, it takes 24 to 48 hours for the photo submission process. 

Success Stories: Promoting Marriage Over Casual Dating

Christian Mingle and eharmony both work wonders in helping members find real relationships. But it’s still interesting to read some of the latest success stories and see how each of these premium dating sites serves their members.

eharmony: From Love at First Sight to 10 Years of Marriage

According to some stats, eharmony’s matchmaking system is responsible for nearly 4% of U.S. marriages. The eharmony team boasts that more than 600,000 couples who met on eharmony have tied the knot, and some have shared their stories on eharmony’s website. Let’s look at some of those stories to show you what you can expect from eharmony.

Let’s start with Brittany and Willie, who fell in love at first sight. They started their first conversation on eharmony in 2018, and they haven’t stopped talking since. Brittany said she knew he was the one by the end of their first date. The two felt they were made for each other and were married in a romantic ceremony in Paris at the beginning of 2020. They welcomed their first child in 2021 and are excited to raise their son together.

Young couple smiling and laughing faces pressed together
For some couples who met on eharmony, it was love at first sight.

Another story, from Anne and Brian from Hillsboro, Oregon, shows that the eharmony matching system does pick the right partner.

After moving to a small town in Texas after graduating college, Anne realized her search for love would be tough with a limited dating pool. When she didn’t have luck with other dating apps, she decided to try eharmony. She was impressed with how thorough the Personality Profile was and even thought to herself, “I just pray this works!”

A few weeks later, she matched with Brian. They agreed to wear the silliest outfits on their first dinner date in 2010 and have been inseparable ever since. Now, they have been married for 10 years.

These heartwarming stories are evidence that eharmony works to help real people find long-lasting love. Your journey to find love could be just one click away on eharmony. Soon, you may share your successful love story with eharmony and inspire others to try it.

Christian Mingle: Trust God (and the Algorithm) to Find a Perfect Match

You don’t have to take the success of Christian Mingle on faith because its members happily share their love stories online. Given the nature of the site, most couples feel grateful that God helped them find their partner through Christian Mingle. When people share the same faith, their journey to saying, ‘I do,’ may seem like divine guidance leading them to their vows.

Let’s meet Alexandra and Tim, who said that God gave them much more than they asked for. And they ended up very happy.

Man and woman praying and holding hands in church
Christian Mingle couples like Alexandra and Tim enjoyed getting to know each other after attending church together.

“He got in touch first. We exchanged messages and emails, and then he took the initiative to come and visit me in Boston since he was living in Kentucky. It was a very kind, respectful meeting, we went to watch the church service in the morning and spent the rest of the day with a good conversation, then we took a tour of the city. The next day, we met again, we had lunch together, and he presented me with a massage session on Envy, flowers, and other gifts, and another tour of the city of Boston,” Alexandra said.

“In my moments of prayer, I asked God for specific demonstrations of love on his part,” Alexandra continued. “And as time went by, I had evidence that God was in charge of this relationship and choice for my life!”

The couple gives a piece of advice to those who are still looking for love and want to give Christian Mingle a try. “Do not be in a hurry, pray a lot, and try to know the past, the purpose of your future partner, who loves God above all!”

If you are still unsure about Christian Mingle, Jenny and Daniel want to ensure you don’t let fear hold you back.

Older Black couple laughing at a coffee shop over cake
Sometimes even matches made online are still matches made in “heaven”.

“We met at Panera for dinner. Our first date lasted three hours there. We got engaged six months after meeting each other. It was just seeing the other person’s heart for the Lord prove to be true in a lot of little moments. We now have a baby and laugh that we met online, but God used it! Be open to it, be prayerful, and don’t let fear hold you back from trying it out,” the pair wrote.

The Winner: eharmony Has Better Reviews Overall

While our research shows both Christian Mingle and eharmony will help singles find long-term partners, the winner is eharmony. The online dating platform serves a wider audience, and its distinctive personality assessment sets the service apart from its competitors. While eharmony premium membership is expensive, the impressive success stories show it is worth the investment.

The only time Christian Mingle beats eharmony is when you’re looking for a faith-driven partner. Finding a partner on Christian Mingle will make the conversation about religion effortless and could lead to a walk down the aisle.

Our experts prefer eharmony to Christian Mingle, but nothing beats first-hand experience. If you’re not a fan of swiping games and want to find the love of your life, eharmony may be your best option. If God plays a significant role in your life, consider giving Christian Mingle a try. Happy dating!

Advertiser Disclosure is a free online resource that offers valuable content and comparison services to users. To keep this resource 100% free, we receive compensation from many of the offers listed on the site. Along with key review factors, this compensation may impact how and where products appear on the page (including, for example, the order in which they appear). does not include the entire universe of available offers. Editorial opinions expressed on the site are strictly our own and are not provided, endorsed, or approved by advertisers. Our Editorial Review Policy Our site is committed to publishing independent, accurate content guided by strict editorial guidelines. Before articles and reviews are published on our site, they undergo a thorough review process performed by a team of independent editors and subject-matter experts to ensure the content’s accuracy, timeliness, and impartiality. Our editorial team is separate and independent of our site’s advertisers, and the opinions they express on our site are their own. To read more about our team members and their editorial backgrounds, please visit our site’s About page.