Key Takeaways

  • Plenty of Fish may be worth trying if you want a dating app with plenty of ways to browse, match, and connect with folks.

  • It offers enough to get started on the free version, but paid features unlock more visibility, unlimited swipes, and more ways to reach people.

  • If you prefer a more curated dating experience or a community built around LGBTQ+ and ENM connections, you may want to explore Match instead.

The first time I heard of Plenty of Fish was in 2012, when my dad told me about his then-girlfriend. “I met her on POF,” he said. “What’s that?” I asked incredulously. He went on to tell me it was a dating app. Nearly 20 years later, in my career as a sex and relationships writer, I’ve tried a lot of dating apps (and I do mean a lot).

But oddly, I’d still never tried out Plenty of Fish for myself — until now. Maybe it was because I’d only ever known my dad to use it. But I started asking friends, and it turns out, a few of them have been on it, too.

So on an Uber ride home, I decided to finally download the app and create a free account. Since then, I’ve been testing it out daily in my pursuit of dating other women-loving-women. I then spent the week swiping, chatting, and even doing a selfie verification to prove I’m not a robot.

It turns out, Plenty of Fish isn’t just for my dad’s age bracket. I felt like Plenty of Fish was worth trying since it has so many ways to browse, match, and connect with folks.

Signup Process & Profile Setup

Plenty of Fish logo beside screenshots of the app’s welcome screen and profile setup prompt.
I downloaded POF on the ride home and got started with a free account—the signup process felt simple but still had enough detail to be meaningful.

Like I said, I downloaded the Plenty of Fish app in the Uber on the way home, so it was pretty simple. It started by asking me for the basics: My name, email, birthday to verify being 18+, and some photos.

The vibe was to choose your best photos, without showing off too much skin, and under no circumstances can you post a photo of your little one without you in it, too. I liked that detail as a safety measure for children, even if I have none of my own.

DatingNews writer Hayley Folk wearing a black sleeveless top in natural sunlight.
Sex and relationships writer Hayley Folk spent a week testing Plenty of Fish for this firsthand review.

Next came the questions: What are you looking for? Do you date smokers? Do you date others who have kids? Most were pretty straightforward, except for the latter option, which only allowed me to answer with a No, Yes, or that I only date single parents. I found the last statement to be a bit confusing in terms of wording.

Then, it asked me for my personality type. It gave a long list of options to choose from — adventurer, blue-collar, coffee snob, princess, hippie, brogrammer, and hopeless romantic, to name a few. I expected to be able to choose multiple. But to my surprise, the app only let me choose one.

C’mon, no one identifies themselves as just blue-collar, right?

Nonetheless, I felt like the rest of the questions were simple but informative to the dating process. Like answering if you drink, smoke, or do drugs. And yes, even if you own a vehicle. Which, for some, could be a dealbreaker.

My Plenty of Fish profile setup, showing personality options, lifestyle questions, and age, distance, and dating preferences.
I chose “Poet” for my personality type, but I was surprised POF only let me choose one — there’s more to me than that!

Browsing, Matching & Messaging: How It Went

Once I made my profile, I was in. The discovery tools felt a lot like other dating apps, with the function to swipe through users on the Meet Me tab, where I could either like, pass, show extra interest to someone (a paid feature), or even rewind if I skipped ahead on someone too quickly.

On the Explore tab, I could refine my search by specifics, such as the intent of their being on the app, ethnicity, body type, religion, marital status, income status, etc. I could also see who is nearby at a glance. POF even offers you a recommended for you section to consider, too. I liked the Explore tab as a change of pace from the monotonous swipe.

“I liked the Explore tab as a change of pace from the monotonous swipe.”

Of course, once you like someone and they like you, it becomes a match. Next? Either of us could message first. Using the free account, I was getting a few matches and able to chat. But the matches came few and far between…

What You Can Do for Free Vs. What You Have to Pay for

Throughout my time on Plenty of Fish, I noticed that the paid version of the app might be a very different experience than the free account I had been using, which anyone can easily download:

Category Rating
★★★★★ 4.1/5.0

Like, rather than swiping until I matched with someone, I could have upgraded my account to have access to things like First Contact.

First Contact is basically a paid feature that allows you to send a chat to another user without ever matching, in the hopes that they’d want to continue the conversation. This removes the whole having-to-match process, but sure, you can message for free too.

Another thing that stood out to me? If I paid for POF Premium, I could find out who liked me immediately, rather than having to match myself. This reminded me of how Feeld’s paid version is, too.

Plus, with paid, you can extend your profile viewing, get unlimited swipes, ad-free experiences, a first look at new members, and even add up to 16 photos on your profile.

Plenty of Fish logo on a salmon colored background

Plus, if you want to go the extra mile, you can upgrade to a higher subscription plan where you get unlimited First Contacts, priority messages, likes, and have access to read receipts. I mean, I would have definitely liked the First Contact thing the most.

While I never paid for any of these features — which are auto-renewed for the same price and length until a user decides to cancel — I could see how they’d feel very meaningful for folks who aren’t just casually dating, but actively looking for serious relationships. 

Plenty of Fish Profiles: What Stood Out to Me

As the week went on, I was starting to notice a pattern for folks in my area: either users were looking for true love or just having casual fun.

When I was swiping through potential matches, I’d click on someone I was interested in to look further into their profile. Most of the time, users kept their About sections short and to the point, unlike a lot of other apps I’ve been on. I set my own filters to look for folks within 20 miles, but the app lets you filter for anywhere, as well. 

Who Uses PoF?

Demographic Percentage
Online Daters Who Have Tried POF 30% of U.S. adults who have ever used online dating have tried POF.
Online Daters Ages 30-49 38% of U.S. online dating users ages 30-49 have tried POF.
Online Daters Ages 50+ 36% of U.S. online dating users ages 50+ have tried POF.

There were only a few matches I made, but most ended up being other fellow polyamorous girlies. On the other hand, I wasn’t as interested in girls looking for unicorns for their marriages, or the one queer woman who openly said in her profile that she wouldn’t date a bisexual woman, like myself.

Remember when I mentioned selfie verification? While Plenty of Fish doesn’t require it, it is one thing that would make me take pause and look at a person’s profile to learn more about them. Otherwise, I found myself wondering why someone wouldn’t do the selfie verification. 

Safety, Privacy & Reporting Tools

Speaking of selfie verification, it’s obviously a great way to practice safety in online dating. But I quickly learned that Plenty of Fish has other safety, privacy and reporting tools in place.

For example, they offer users the option to get verified at any time for free. They also have an easy-to-use Safety Center, where they offer a Crisis Text Line, a reporting guide, a Q&A on how to block someone, support, and more. Like a lot of dating apps, I noticed that POF heavily emphasizes online safety. If they weren’t, it would be a red flag to me. 

In terms of data practices, the app also emphasizes that they never share or sell your private information or profile. Most importantly, they do make sure to emphasize safety before ever meeting with someone IRL.

While I am well-versed in online dating, I appreciated the way they presented it, especially when thinking of folks who maybe are dating on the web for the first time.

I didn’t end up meeting anyone IRL in my week on POF, but I did have a lot of great conversations, and one match that could potentially turn into a date at some point (and hey, I’d do it all with safety in mind thanks to their reminders!)

What Other Plenty of Fish Reviews Say 

Like I said earlier, the only other person I knew who used POF was my dad. But in the spirit of a great review, I wanted to see how other folks are feeling about Plenty of Fish, so I decided to not only ask my friends, but the rest of the internet, too.

Plenty of Fish’s App Store listing, with promotional images showing profiles, a couple, and messaging features.
I downloaded PoF on an Uber ride home and created my first account before the ride was over.

Honestly, the reviews are a bit of a mixed bag, depending on where you look. The App Store shows POF has 4.3 out of 5 stars, out of 1.8 million ratings. Then when I checked Google Play, it showed 3.7 stars from 1.68 million reviews.

Reading through the reviews, some really like the app’s easy-to-use layout and the variety of opportunities to connect with people (like the Explore tab!). Others weren’t as happy.

The most recurring complaints that I saw were about fake profiles, suspected scammers, account issues, customer service, and feeling pressured to pay for additional features. 

Hey, I’d be lying if I said that some of those concerns didn’t line up with my experience. I appreciated having conversations with actual people, but I also found myself paying attention to verification and wondering how genuine some profiles were.

And after my time using my free account, I could see why folks might feel pressure to pay, when there are soooo many more features offered.

Overall, though, I’m glad to know POF is worth exploring for its large dating pool and browsing the profiles, and there’s room for casual and serious daters.

Best Alternatives to Plenty of Fish

These are some of the biggest names in the dating industry, which means their user bases are also much larger. Perhaps a larger dating pool can widen your options. I’d recommend checking out Match and eharmony.

Category Rating
★★★★★ 4.9/5.0
  • Match is the world’s longest running dating site
  • The Discover section has search filters by interests, looks, lifestyle, and more
  • Match is available in 50 countries and 15 languages

This one is for relationship-minded singles for sure. So if you feel like you want to have a little more control over who you’re seeing, Match is worth trying out! Unlike POF’s swipe-and-explore combination, Match puts an emphasis on profile discovery, with custom search options that let you narrow things down.

Free members can message their mutual matches, so it’s reasonable if you want to test the waters before committing to a subscription. The biggest drawback I came across is how some search and discovery tools I am most interested in are behind a paywall.

Category Rating
★★★★★ 4.7/5.0
  • Over 2 million people have found love here
  • Users can filter their match recommendations by age or city
  • Compatibility Quiz identifies common interests, lifestyles, and goals

So, eharmony takes a different approach. For anyone who would rather spend less time swiping and more time thinking about compatibility, eharmony takes a different approach. The platform starts with a good ol’ fashioned Compatibility Quiz, which uses your answers to build a personality profile and recommend potential partners based on compatibility.

Compared to POF, the sign-up process and quiz together make it more involved. So it might take a while to get through, but it’s worth it! I could join for free, browse member profiles, and send and receive initial Likes, but some features are restricted. 

If you want to be matched based on more than just a few profile photos, this one is for you. 

What I Liked and What I Didn’t Like About Plenty of Fish

After spending a week on Plenty of Fish, I definitely see why people keep coming back to it. I personally really liked having more ways to discover people beyond the exhaustive swipe experience. I also liked being able to match and message without having to pay. Some apps charge you to pay for messages, after all.

Pros

  • I could match and message for free.
  • I liked how the interface wasn’t swipe-based.
  • I had good conversations and a few promising connections.

Cons

  • I could only choose one personality type.
  • I couldn’t see who liked me without upgrading.
  • My matches were few and far between.
  • Some profiles left me questioning their authenticity.

Of course, the paid features can start to feel really tempting trying to get. I can understand wanting more visibility, and it’s hard to see that my interest is piling up, but I couldn’t see the faces that liked me. I enjoyed exploring its different discovery features, chatting with people, and finding a few potential connections along the way.

So, Is It Worth It?

Is Plenty of Fish perfect? Definitely not. Between questionable profiles and the temptation to upgrade, there are a few things I’d like to see improved. But the good news is, I didn’t need to pay to find out whether PoF was right for me.

My advice to friends? Start with the free account, see who’s in the area, and decide from there whether it’s worth upgrading.