The Scoop: Supermarket Italy began in 2009 as a family-owned specialty shop for imported Italian and European goods. Its international catalogue includes pastas, meats, cheeses, and tomato sauces — aka the perfect ingredients for making a delicious and authentic pizza or pasta dinner on a date night. Shopping at Supermarket Italy can be a fun way to elevate your kitchen game and bring a taste of Europe to your table. Organic, gluten-free, and keto diet options are available, and shipping is free for all orders over $50.

Pizza was one of the first things I learned how to make for dinner as a young college kid, and it became my go-to if I was hosting a friend or a date at my apartment. After all, who doesn’t like homemade pizza?

My cooking skills are limited, but my pizzas have impressed many a dinner guest over the years. I’ve found that pizza is an adaptable dish that can be as simple (plain cheese, extra sauce) or as inventive (mac and cheese pizza with bacon and sausage) as I like. And it doesn’t take very long or very much attention to make, so it leaves a lot of room for conversation in the kitchen.

If you’re planning a dinner date at home in the near future, I’d recommend heading to the Supermarket Italy online store to find pizza ingredients that are a cut above what you’d find at the typical grocery store. Supermarket Italy imports goods from Europe and has authentic pizza and pasta ingredients that’ll have foodies asking for seconds.

Supermarket Italy logo

Supermarket Italy can supply home chefs with specialty goods from Europe.

Americans can take a culinary tour of Europe thanks to Supermarket Italy. From fresh olives and capers to pancetta and prosciutto, the catalogue includes a large variety of classic Italian favorites — meaning at-home chefs have a lot of flavors and toppings to add to their favorite dishes.

Instead of ordering a pizza from a chain restaurant or attempting a complicated recipe, couples can treat themselves to a homemade pizza and take some of the stress out of their date nights. Supermarket Italy has the cheeses, meats, sauces, and veggies — and also a pizza makers bundle — to ensure the flavors are delizioso!

“Our mission is to provide people in the U.S. with an international, gourmet food experience,” said Marketing & SEO Content Director Taylor Markarian,. “The vast majority of our items are imported from other countries — with a particular focus on Italian food. We want to provide you with everything you need to make inspiring and authentic dishes at home.”

The Online Grocery Store Specializes in Real Italian Food

Americans from across the country have used Supermarket Italy to stock their kitchens with unique flavorful ingredients. Some have even gotten gourmet gift baskets here.

Taylor said the Supermarket Italy team takes pride in the quality and authenticity of its products. “We carry products from all over the world,” he told us. “That excites and inspires us.”

Photo of olives

Fresh olives can add a nice finishing touch to a date night cocktail hour.

The online inventory has the staples of classic Italian food, which naturally starts with pasta. The pasta types range from angel hair to stuffed shells, and they represent a long tradition of Italian cooking.

Olives are another popular item. The store has a variety of green, red, and black olives sourced from Italian growers.

The store’s extensive meat selection includes whole legs of Italian prosciutto as well as premium cuts of pork and sausage. Carnivores can enjoy adding the Italian-style beef meatballs or tapas chorizo to their favorite pasta dishes. Meanwhile vegan and vegetarian cooks can check out the growing plant-based meat products as a substitute for salami, turkey, or prosciutto.

Finally, we have to talk about the imported cheeses. Supermarket Italy has dozens of types of cheeses ranging from Asiago to Swiss. The grated parmesan is perfect for sprinkling over just about any Italian dish, while the gooey melted cheese fondue can provide a fun hands-on appetizer.

Pizza makers can add greater complexity to their pies by sprinkling a bit of goat cheese, gorgonzola, or manchego on top just before putting it in the oven. The sharpness of these cheeses can pair well with hearty meats and peppers. Just be sure to OK the flavor combos with your date as these ingredients can be polarizing.

Whether you’re making a pizza or a charcuterie board for your date, Supermarket Italy’s cheese inventory has a lot of options to tantalize the taste buds with memorable flavors.

A Great Recipe Can Be the Starter for Romance offers unique bundles for making easy Italian recipes at home. For example, the homemade pizza bundle offers the sauce, flour, and cheese to make an authentic Neapolitan pizza, plus it includes a Bialetti Pizza Chopper for easy serving.

The Spaghetti with Bottarga Bundle includes the basics for a spicy seafood pasta dish that is simple to make and will impress dinner guests.

Photo of Sanniti balsamic glazed carrots

The recipe blog can walk beginners through the basics of Italian and European cooking.

Supermarket Italy partners with Mmmediterranean to give online customers access to freshly caught seafood, including shrimp, octopus, lobster, and clams. It also has Italian coffee courtesy of premium coffee brands Lavazza and Kimbo.

Not sure how to incorporate rare European ingredients into a dateworthy meal? Then check out the recipe blog for inspiration. The blog details recipes for healthy appetizers, viral food trends, homemade pasta, and Italian comfort food. It also has general cooking tips and ingredient profiles to help home chefs learn how to make the most of their meal times.

Over the years, Supermarket Italy has provided the ingredients for dinner dates, family meals, and so many more eating experiences. Its flavors naturally create enriching memories, and cooking with such specialty items can be a great way to show love and devotion to that special someone.

One husband messaged the Supermarket Italy team in hopes of finding the right Italian ingredients to make pizzas for his pregnant wife. “He was desperate for a certain type of Italian 00 flour,” Taylor recalled. “It was funny and sweet how important it was to him to make it for her.”

The right recipe can give couples warm and fuzzy feelings that last long after dessert. If you’re hoping to inspire romance, maybe start with an Italian cocktail or a charcuterie board to get a conversation going while a pizza cooks in the oven or pasta simmers on the stove.

Supermarket Italy Brings Fresh Flavor to Your Doorstep

It may sound cheesy, but a pizza can be a satisfying and indulgent treat on a date. As a teen, I discovered pizza was cheap and easy to make, and it became the dish I used to impress friends and dates alike. Making a pizza at home is a lighthearted and stress-free activity that prompts couples to explore their favorite flavors and get their hands floury.

Supermarket Italy can be a wingman to a pizza lovers date by offering tons of flavorful cheeses, sauces, and toppings. It even has Italian pizza flour to add an airy texture to the crust.

If you’re craving Italian food, you don’t have to book a flight to the Mediterranean, simply go online to Supermarket Italy and order specialty items that are authentic, fresh, and delicious. The inventory goes above and beyond the typical American grocery and has a lot of intriguing and rare foods available for doorstep delivery.

To help spread the word about this culinary supply, Supermarket Italy has a Shopify affiliate program that unites creatives and influencers behind the brand.

“We are always looking to expand our inventory and grow our audience,” Taylor told us. “We are eager to collaborate with influencers and affiliate publications so that we may bring international gourmet food to more American kitchens.”

Advertiser Disclosure is a free online resource that offers valuable content and comparison services to users. To keep this resource 100% free, we receive compensation from many of the offers listed on the site. Along with key review factors, this compensation may impact how and where products appear on the page (including, for example, the order in which they appear). does not include the entire universe of available offers. Editorial opinions expressed on the site are strictly our own and are not provided, endorsed, or approved by advertisers. Our Editorial Review Policy Our site is committed to publishing independent, accurate content guided by strict editorial guidelines. Before articles and reviews are published on our site, they undergo a thorough review process performed by a team of independent editors and subject-matter experts to ensure the content’s accuracy, timeliness, and impartiality. Our editorial team is separate and independent of our site’s advertisers, and the opinions they express on our site are their own. To read more about our team members and their editorial backgrounds, please visit our site’s About page.